Was Amnesia your first horror game?

[BrooksyFC]

Amnesia was the first one I finished. I had tried Penumbra Overture but never moved further than the first dog encounter. Don't really know what made me finish Amnesia, perhaps, the story seemed more interesting or the castle atmosphere. I still want to play all three Penumbra games, but didn't have enough time since there are so many good Amnesia custom stories.

Overture is brilliant. If you think the first dog is scary, which I thought it was, wait until you get further. I'm not gunna ruin it for you, but it gets worse I'm gunna start playing Black Plague in the new year, looks a lot scarier. Plus all the Penumbra games have a great story to them.