Was Amnesia your first horror game?

[A Tricky Carnie]

The first horror game I was exposed to was Silent Hill 2, I watched my sister play through the whole game, and I couldn't sleep at all for weeks (I was probably about 9-10).

The first horror game I played was F.E.A.R., but I never finished it. The first horror game I finished was Resident Evil 4 Wii edition (I owned on the PS2 as well but never beat it, I found aiming on the Wii much easier than with the PS2 controller). Then eventually I picked up Dead Space and Dead Space 2.

After seeing the Zero Punctuation review for Minecraft, I started to watch his older videos, which led me to his Amnesia review (which I didn't think much of at the time.) Then on a horror games thread on another forum, someone linked the "HOLY SHIT AMNESIA WHAT THE FUCK" video, which ultimately led to me and my friend buying it, and doing a Let's Play of it (Amnesia is now my favorite game of all time, seconded only by The Binding of Isaac). After Amnesia I decided to check out the Penumbra games, beat Overture and Black Plague, but never got far with Requiem.