Games in which you felt more immersed than in Amnesia

[Kreekakon]

The most I've felt immersed by a game really depends on how broad the definition of "immersion" is.

If we're talking about general you "feel" like the character I'd say it would have to be Skyrim, and Amnesia.

In a broader sense of the game being VERY engaging to play, and it just sucks you in with its plot, and/or gameplay I'd go with the Bioshock series, IB, and Fire Emblem Awakening just to name a couple.