Amnesia: The Dark Descent or Penumbra: The Black Plague?

[Cuyir]

My favorite Frictional games game has always been Black Plague. Overture was sort of disappointing and while Amnesia: The Dark Descent did many many many things well it sort of petered out towards the end.

Black Plague also made me feel a connection to Amabel, Clarence and Red while in Amnesia you were alone alone. Clarence gave the game a nice little wrinkle too. Plus I found Penumbra's world more interesting than Amnesia's.