Games in which you felt more immersed than in Amnesia

[Walter White]

Alan Wake, When I first played it I was sold the enemy encounters was a little over the top at times tho, but story wise I felt very immersed, and I'm still wondering how it all end! (dont wanna spoil anything)

I agree!! Alan Wake is such a great game! The landscapes are awesome, the story, everything is perfect. Sam Lake is an awesome writer!
_
I can't say that I felt more immersed in Return To Castle Wolfenstein than in Amnesia, but I remember that when i was young I was playing RTCW alone and i reached the catacombs, (it's the second level, or third) and undead start showing up out of nowhere!! I got so scared that i clicked the Reset button on my pc and i uninstalled the game afterwards haha!