(01-01-2015, 10:13 PM)Ashtoreth Wrote: I don't know exactly how to explain it, but it made me realise that sometimes soundtracks kind of "tell you" what you should feel instead of letting you feel it by yourself.
This is certainly often the case - but the real magic in music lies in expressing abstract emotions. Moods you cannot paint with words or visuals because they don't really exist. When paired with visuals or a narrative, it can introduce meanings which don't follow naturally from the scene itself. Instead of telling you what to feel by forming resonance with what's on the screen, music can become a character in its own right by offering its own unique perspective, not unlike cinematography or lighting, which technically are not directly perceived either. Even simple scenes can become complex if the music suggests something other than what is being shown -
especially if the music doesn't directly reference idioms we connect with certain emotions - stereotypically sad music or heroic music for example (e.g. the music is itself simple, as in one-dimensional). But you're right, sometimes silence is golden.
EDIT: This is often done beautifully in noir films. Possibly my favorite example is the ending to Chinatown: