Noticed Amnesia's icon only goes as high as 32x32 I believe, so I think it's perhaps a good idea to start create some high resolution ones for those who like to show-off their desktop.
First one:
A nice one of the perhaps most feared servant, the Brute. Icon has transparency and only supports full colours, but who uses 256 colours or lower these days anyway?
Download here, as in most cases, it needs to be an ICO file.
Bit dramatic, but thought it would be a nice touch to have a lantern laying with some blood over it... Might as well put in the shortcut details: "You have to carry on..."
Edit: If needed, I can also make a Mac-version of the Grunt icon. I'f I'm not mistaken, I remember Mac icons using a different format and even go as high as 512x512.