First, FEAR, but I never actually finished it, 'cause after some time, it became vevry veeeeeeeeeeery boooooring... And then I searched for more horror games and then I've met Amnesia, but it looked TOO FUCKING SCARY, but I liked the engine that I saw on the trailer, so I searched more about it and I found Penumbra. I played Penumbra first because I thought it was less scarier than Amnesia. And when I finished the series, I played Amnesia. I took a long time in the first 10 minutes of Amnesia, like, playing 5 seconds every day, but after this, a map a day... But I preferred the story of Penumbra... Why am I saying all of that in a topic called "Was Amnesia your first horror game?"? I don't know.